These are items on Earl's List that were never reveled what numbers they were.
Season 1[]
- Unnumbered list item 1 - Broke a window 15 years ago of former neighbor John Sheppard ("Cost Dad the Election")
- Unnumbered list item 2 - Broke Dodge and Earl Jr.'s Christmas bikes ("White Lie Christmas")
- Unnumbered list item 3 - Took donuts from a bank where I was not a customer ("Barn Burner")
- Unnumbered list item 4 - Stole a birdbath out of a pickup truck ("Barn Burner")
- Unnumbered list item 5 - Had an affair with Sherry and Linda ("Barn Burner")
- Unnumbered list item 6 - Robbed a house while friends sang Christmas carols ("Y2K")
Season 2[]
- Unnumbered list item 7 - Stole Sebastian's chance to be a proud champion ("Larceny of a Kitty Cat")
- Unnumbered list item 8 - Ruined Wills chance with Wendy ("Mailbox")
- Unnumbered list item 9 - Got Darnell kicked out of his trailer ("Mailbox")
- Unnumbered list item 10 - Renamed the playground game smear-the-Kenny ("Born a Gamblin' Man")
- Unnumbered list item 11 - Pulled pranks on Randy ("The Birthday Party")
- Unnumbered list item 12 - Peed on Mom's rug ("The Birthday Party")
- Unnumbered list item 13 - Got Darnell stoned (literally) ("The Birthday Party")
- Unnumbered list item 14 - Almost got Donny Jones killed by a fern ("The Birthday Party")
- Unnumbered list item 15 - Made fun of Joy being pregnant ("The Birthday Party")
- Unnumbered list item 16 - Almost got Dad divorced and gave him a back problem ("The Birthday Party")
- Unnumbered list item 17 - Stole DJ Dave's equipment except one turntable ("The Birthday Party")
- Unnumbered list item 18 - Stole Slow Roger's car and slept with his sister ("The Birthday Party")
- Unnumbered list item 19 - Cost Patty the Daytime Hooker a client ("Harassed a Reporter")
- Unnumbered list item 20 - Robbed a deaf woman in Camden County ("The Trial")
Season 3[]
- Unnumbered list item 21 - Used Glen Shipley to help steal when they were children ("My Name Is Inmate 28301-016 (Part 1)")
- Unnumbered list item 22 - Made a healer boy scared of his own hands ("I Won't Die with a Little Help from My Friends (Part 2)")
- Unnumbered list item 23 - Stole a TV ("Girl Earl")
Season 4[]
- Unnumbered list item 24 - Stole Buddy's childhood dream ("The Magic Hour")
- Unnumbered list item 25 - Kept Kenny from his dreams of cheerleading ("We've Got Spirit")
- Unnumbered list item 26 - Made Randy drink toilet water when he was eight and ten ("We've Got Spirit")
- Unnumbered list item 27 - Cost Randy a little brother ("Little Bad Voodoo Brother")
- Unnumbered list item 28 - Sold a guy a lemon car ("Sold a Guy a Lemon Car")
- Unnumbered list item 29 - Put a dent in the Crab Shack bar ("Earl and Joy's Anniversary")
- Unnumbered list item 30 - Got the Babysitter Pregnant ("Got the Babysitter Pregnant")
- Unnumbered list item 31 - Stole Chaz Dalton's space suit ("Chaz Dalton's Space Academy")
- Unnumbered list item 32 - Made Randy Scared of ties ("Dodge's Dad")